The tradition of asking for a pony (or a horse) for Christmas is a venerable one. I'm sure that the origins of the pony-for-Christmas go back centuries, but I was interested to see what references to kids and horses and holidays turned up online. So I went to Newspapers.com and did a search for the phrase "pony for Christmas."
One of the oldest examples of that phrase being used in one of the archived newspapers was in the 1887 Philadelphia Times. With a nod to Louisa May Alcott, the paper described the lives of several "little men and women" of the area, noting that little Emma Rutter was being trained by her older sisters to ask Santa Claus to bring her a pony for Christmas.
A somewhat saccharine story was published in several 1910 newspapers: the tale of Little Boy Bulger, who was naughty at Christmastime, but repented of his evil ways, apologized to his parents, and was rewarded with a pony as a New Year's present.
I found many examples of ads for Ponies for Christmas. This one from Indiana dates to 1889.
Just before Christmas 1910, the Allentown (PA) Democrat carried this ad that promoted the health benefits of pony ownership, as well as the fact that a pony made an "attractive and useful lawn ornament."
The Pampa (TX) Daily News showed us the conflict that could occur when one parent approved of A Pony For Christmas and the other didn't, circa Christmas 1936.
By the 1950s, it was even harder for parents to ignore the idea of a horse as a companion because there were so many of them on television, ridden by cowboy heroes.
Unlike the protagonist in Lincoln Steffins' classic story "A Miserable, Merry Christmas," I never said that if I couldn't have a horse for Christmas I wanted nothing at all. I always settled for receiving a new model horse figurine, and once my parents thought I was Too Old For Things Like That, I started buying myself a model horse every Christmas.
Last Christmas, I bought myself a little Hagen-Renaker mini Western Pony foal. This darling little fellow was designed by Maureen Love and only released in Spring and Fall 1957. He has been through the wars but he has a safe home on my shelves now.
You can read "A Miserable, Merry Christmas" for free here: